Skip to main content

2018 Head-to-Head Crossbow Test

Modern crossbows deliver ultimate performance'but which reigns supreme?

2018 Head-to-Head Crossbow Test

There is no longer an argument on whether a crossbow fits into a sustainable niche in the hunter's toolbox. With velocities well over 400 feet per second and accuracy that would make some rifles envious, the verdict is in and crossbows are here to stay. We have seen the crossbow industry evolve and explode over the past decade, thanks to an expanding market and an aging cohort of bowhunters. Due to that demand, crossbows have become more powerful and increasingly accurate in addition to being more compact and durable.

The good news is that crossbows are better than ever. The bad news is that the choices can be a bit overwhelming, especially to buyers not familiar with the market. To help hunters decide which bow might be best for their needs, we evaluated five market leaders and measured their respective strengths and weaknesses. As we have done in previous years, we tested for portability, accuracy, trigger pull, velocity, and ergonomics.

Ravin R20: 24.5 Score

Ravin R20The Ravin R20 suffers from an identity crisis: It thinks it's a rifle. The worst thing about shooting the Ravin is recovering the bolts from the target because they penetrate so deeply. This bow is fast and accurate, has a great trigger, and is well constructed. The R20 is pretty long, but thanks to its light weight and narrow width, it still earns top marks in terms of portability. Other than the steep price tag, it's hard to find anything on this bow not to like. MSRP: $2,150

  • Weight - 8 lbs. 2.4 oz.
  • Length - 34.5 in.
  • Width Cocked - 9.12 in.
  • Accuracy - 1.0 in. (25 yds.)
  • Trigger Pull - 2 lbs. 9.2 oz.
  • Velocity - 428 fps

TenPoint Nitro X: 23.5 Score

TenPoint Nitro XTenPoint upped its game this year with a bow that matches the Ravin in terms of velocity when using the 370-grain Pro Lite arrow. I hog hunted with this bow earlier in the year and saw its effectiveness firsthand. This bow was the fastest that we tested, and it also received high marks for its trigger pull and accuracy. The ACUdraw cocking system is slightly more cumbersome to operate than some that we tested, but it gets the job done. TenPoint bows are well built, and this American company stands behind its products. MSRP: $2,050


  • Weight - 9 lbs. 11 oz.
  • Length - 29 in.
  • Width Cocked - 10.5 in.
  • Accuracy - 1.7 in. (25 yds.)
  • Trigger Pull - 3 lbs. 14 oz.
  • Velocity - 431 fps

Mission SUB-1: 22 Score

Mission SUB-1The score doesn't necessarily reflect how much we liked this bow. It was well built, relatively quiet, and very accurate. The only downside to this bow is that it must be cocked manually, otherwise we would have given it 5 points for ergonomics (an RSD crank is available for $189). To our eyes, the Hawke optic included with the Mission had the best glass in our test. If your hunting situation doesn't require extremely high velocity, this is a bow to consider. MSRP: $1,500


  • Weight - 8 lbs. 15 oz.
  • Length - 30.5 in.
  • Width Cocked - 14.75 in.
  • Accuracy - 1.1 in. (25 yds.)
  • Trigger Pull - 2 lbs. 14.3 oz.
  • Velocity - 346 fps

Excalibur Assassin: 21 Score

Excalibur AssassinIn years past, our chief complaint of the recurve Excalibur bows has been the effort required to cock them. We can cross that off the list thanks to the company's new Charger Crank System, which requires only 12 pounds of force to cock the bow. The Assassin also features a user-adjustable stock that can be quickly adapted for different lengths of pull and comb heights to accommodate varying body and clothing types. Say what you will about recurve bows, they are durable and simple. You have to hand it to the folks at Excalibur: They are keeping the recurve bow relevant with their innovations. MSRP: $1,600

  • Weight - 9 lbs. 5 oz.
  • Length - 30 in.
  • Width Cocked - 21 in.
  • Accuracy - 1.3 in. (25 yds.)
  • Trigger Pull - 3 lbs. 8.6 oz.
  • Velocity - 354 fps

Barnett Whitetail Pro RDX: 19 Score

Barnett Whitetail ProThis was the least-expensive crossbow we tested — by a healthy margin. This Barnett's performance wasn't on par with the other models tested, but neither is the price tag. The TriggerTech trigger broke cleanly at just over four pounds, and the bow was very portable, thanks in part to its light weight. The bow had to be cocked manually, but a crank cocking device is available as an option. For a casual crossbow hunter looking to fill a deer tag during archery season without spending a bundle, this bow would be tough to beat. MSRP: $600

  • Weight - 8 lbs.
  • Length - 36 in.
  • Width Cocked - 16.5 in.
  • Accuracy - 2.7 in. (25 yds.)
  • Trigger Pull - 4 lbs. 4.2 oz.
  • Velocity - 371 fps
  • The Findings

    We evaluated five attributes of each model (portability, trigger pull, accuracy, ergonomics, and velocity) and recorded the results. In each category, a score of 0-5 was given with 5 points being the highest. There is definitely a human factor in this test, particularly in the ergonomics category. Petersen's Hunting first asked me to conduct this test a few years ago because I have very little exposure to the archery market and am about as unbiased as it gets in terms of brand preference. Though I have learned a great deal about these products after testing so many, I have kept my relationships with the crossbow industry at arms-length.

    Portability

    This may matter a great deal to you or not at all, depending on your preferred hunting style. I suspect that most crossbow hunters are using treestands and off-road vehicles, but that's not always the case. Some crossbow designs can be pretty unwieldy to carry afield, which can make for a long day on a spot-and-stalk hunt. To accurately evaluate the portability of these crossbows, we used our previously established formula based on size and weight. Each bow was weighed with only the factory-mounted optics included. We measured each bow's width at the greatest outside point as well as its length. Our formula combined the weight in total ounces, the cocked outside width in inches, and the length in inches. The lower the number, the higher the score.


    Trigger Pull

    A trigger on a crossbow is a tricky device. Not only does it have to safely hold back hundreds of pounds of force, but also it must be able to release that force with just a few pounds of pressure. We tested the weight of each bow's trigger using a Lyman digital trigger pull scale. As in 2017, the Ravin earned a full five points with a pull weight of under three pounds. The Mission also received five points, with a pull just a fraction higher than that of the Ravin. None of the trigger pulls on any of the bows were a detriment to accuracy during our testing.

    Ergonomics

    This is the least objective portion of the test, and some human bias is probably present. Essentially, this category is "how much I liked the bow" and considers factors such as ease of cocking and loading, handling characteristics, safety features, noise level, ease of assembly, and overall design. The Ravin and Mission bows received full points here thanks

    to being solidly built and user-friendly. Unlike years past, each bow performed satisfactorily, and there isn't a bow in this test that I would hesitate to hunt with.


    Accuracy

    Three three-shot groups were fired from each bow at 25 yards, and the outside spread was measured with a 0.001-inch caliper and averaged. Candidly, all these bows shot very well. The Ravin shot the tightest groups, beating the Mission

    by a mere 0.1 inch. The Excalibur and TenPoint were right on the tails of those bows, with only the Barnett falling above the two-inch mark. In terms of translation to the field, I wouldn't hesitate to hunt with any of these bows at 50 yards.

    Velocity

    To measure the muzzle velocity, each bow was fired over a ProChrono Pal chronograph at a distance of three feet. We fired three shots and averaged the results. Last year, the Ravin R15 stood high above the rest of the pack, but it didn't hold the title long. The TenPoint Nitro X edged-out the Ravin in terms of speed, besting it by a mere three feet per second on average. The other three bows all hovered in the 340- to 370-fps range, which, practically speaking, is pretty darn fast.

    GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

    Recommended Articles

    See More Recommendations

    Popular Videos

    Camp Chef at SHOT Show: Elk Venison Slider Burgers Recipe

    Camp Chef at SHOT Show: Elk Venison Slider Burgers Recipe

    Have a freezer full of ground elk venison from your fall hunting trips? Never fear, the folks at Camp Chef have a great SHOT Show recipe that is lean and mean, easy to prepare, and a crowd-pleasing favorite!

    B&C Typical Mule Deer

    B&C Typical Mule Deer

    Doug Burris Jr's typical mule deer taken in 1969, could just be one record that will never be broken.

    Stuffed Elk Backstrap Recipe

    Stuffed Elk Backstrap Recipe

    Take your venison loin to a whole new level with this delicious reverse-seared stuffed elk backstrap. Smoking the backstrap on a Camp Chef Woodwind pellet grill first, then finishing it on a blazing-hot skillet or flattop, creates a perfectly cooked, medium-rare steak with a crispy, seared exterior. The filling of diced mushrooms and creamy Boursin cheese adds a whole new level of amazing flavors to an otherwise classic smoked venison loin.

    Top Ten Hunts

    Top Ten Hunts

    Here at Petersen's Hunting we have compiled the 10 best hunts caught on camera from the last 2 years of Petersen's Hunting TV. Enjoy!

    See More Popular Videos

    Trending Articles

    Technology is taking deer hunters, and their gear, into the future. The Best New Deer Hunting Technology Accessories

    The Best New Deer Hunting Technology

    Jeff Johnston - May 15, 2020

    Technology is taking deer hunters, and their gear, into the future.

    A new wave of allergies threatens to turn hunters into vegetarians; learn more about this tick-transmitted problem.Ticks Making People Allergic to Meat News

    Ticks Making People Allergic to Meat

    David Hart

    A new wave of allergies threatens to turn hunters into vegetarians; learn more about this...

    This recipe adds a little something extra to already-perfect venison backstrap – a sweet and spicy relish made with white-flesh peaches.Venison Backstrap with Sweet & Spicy Peach Relish Recipe Recipes

    Venison Backstrap with Sweet & Spicy Peach Relish Recipe

    Jack Hennessy

    This recipe adds a little something extra to already-perfect venison backstrap – a sweet and...

    See More Trending Articles

    More Bowhunting

    Crossbow technology, accuracy and power continue to advance with demand, and this year's crop is the most impressive yet; here's a look at the top five that caught our eye.Ranking the 5 Best Crossbows for 2020 Bowhunting

    Ranking the 5 Best Crossbows for 2020

    Chris Larsen - September 21, 2020

    Crossbow technology, accuracy and power continue to advance with demand, and this year's crop...

    We put 5 of the year's most popular crossbows to the test. See which one delivered the ultimate performance!2018 Head-to-Head Crossbow Test Bowhunting

    2018 Head-to-Head Crossbow Test

    Keith Wood - September 12, 2018

    We put 5 of the year's most popular crossbows to the test. See which one delivered the...

    New products, born of innovation and ingenuity, are the hallmarks of the bowhunting industry, whereBest Cutting Edge Bow Products for 2017 Bowhunting

    Best Cutting Edge Bow Products for 2017

    PH Online Editors - August 18, 2017

    New products, born of innovation and ingenuity, are the hallmarks of the bowhunting industry,...

    Not many years ago, crossbows were seen as a novelty among hunters. You were more likely to see aHead-to-Head Review: Top Crossbows of 2015 Bowhunting

    Head-to-Head Review: Top Crossbows of 2015

    Keith Wood - July 24, 2015

    Not many years ago, crossbows were seen as a novelty among hunters. You were more likely to...

    See More Bowhunting

    Magazine Cover

    GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save.

    Digital Now Included!

    SUBSCRIBE NOW

    Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

    PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

    Buy Digital Single Issues

    Don't miss an issue.
    Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

    Buy Single Digital Issue on the Petersen's Hunting App

    Other Magazines

    Special Interest Magazines

    See All Special Interest Magazines

    GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

    Phone Icon

    Get Digital Access.

    All Petersen's Hunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

    To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

    Get Digital Access

    Not a Subscriber?
    Subscribe Now